Time for West Indies Cricket to Break Up?

Since the late 1970s I felt strongly that the concept of a West Indies cricket team was outdated and that the region should have broken up into 5 or 6 teams playing international cricket in their own right; namely, Jamaica, Barbados, Trinidad & Tobago, Guyana and/or Combined Windward and Leeward Islands.

The cricketing (male) talent in the West Indies since the 1940s has been bountiful and yet its full potential was never allowed to maximise itself on the international scale. Thus too many good young players left the sport – over the decades – due to a lack of opportunities within the region.

I felt when the Caribbean islands started to gain independence, from colonialism since the 1960s, the regional cricketing administrators should have laid the foundation to go their own separate cricketing ways.

The Caribbean has always had the players, a rich cricketing pedigree, the passion and pride, the environment to make such a momentous move sustainable and rewarding.

Recently, the West Indies cricket selectors found themselves in an awkward position when picking a full-strength squad for the tour of Bangladesh, as many of the first team players decided to opt out including captains Jason Holder (test) and Kieron Pollard (ODIs).

As you can imagine some Bangladeshi cricket officials felt miffed by this overwhelming snub by the more recognizable players from the West Indies. No surprise then that the host whitewashed the West Indies 3-0 in the ODIs.

But when we saw the West Indies squad for the 2 test match series some felt the new players chosen would be classed as rejects or stop-gaps. Yet some of these newer recruits should have been in the test team ages ago based on their form and attitude in local/regional cricket; Nkrumah Bonner a prime example. Despite seeing him play just a handful of matches, Joshua Da Silva had shown a lot of potential for test cricket.

Some of us despairing Windies fans were hoping that the fresh faces in the test team would seize their moment, play exceedingly well and make life interesting for those senior players who opted out. Result!

So high praises to debutants Kyle Mayers and Nkrumah Bonner (man of the series) for their special performances in ensuring the West Indies chased down a record score to win the first test. Mayers was man of the match.

Bonner, Da Silva and Alzarri Joseph showed maturity and confidence with their batting in the 2nd test where Rakheem Cornwall played a match winning role with ball and in the slips to complete a 2-0 victory over the host. Proving once again the cricketing talent in the Caribbean is deep but not truly developed.

Interestingly, as that first test was on its way, a T10 overs tournament was being held in Abu Dhabi which involved at least 22 West Indian cricketers including many who snubbed the tour to Bangladesh.

There is no way that any other cricketing nation would have allowed their senior players to play some micky-mouse-well-paid lavish tournament when some of those said players would be have been expected to be padded up for the national side. This is the core of the issue today for me on the relevance of Team West Indies cricket.

  • Can the West Indies team truly be regarded as a national team?
  • Is the concept of Team West Indian cricket relevant given the independence status that most member nations have acquired since the 1960s?
  • Is the West Indies cricket concept selling its players, fans short by having 11 players instead of 55/66 representing the region at any one time?

West Indies Cricket Should Have Broken Up in the 1970

The (male) teams of Barbados, Trinidad & Tobago, Guyana, Jamaica and the Combined Windward and Leeward Islands were worthy of test status since the 1960s due to its wealth of talent on display at the regional, club and junior levels.

  • The depth in quality was just unreal.
    • Guyana (then British Guiana) in the 1965-66 season of the regional tournament included Lance Gibbs, Joe Solomon, Rohan Kanhai, Roy Fredricks, Basil Butcher, Clive Lloyd and Steven Camacho, all test players.
      • Barbados team then had David Holford, Conrad Hunte, Charlie Griffiths, Seymour Nurse and a certain Garfield Sobers.
    • Barbados alone in the 1970s/1980s could call on the services of world class fast bowlers such as Wayne Daniel, Malcolm Marshall, Keith Boyce, Ezra Mosley (R.I.P.), Franklyn Stephenson, Joel Garner, Sylvester Clarke, Vanburn Holder and Hartley Alleyne.
      • Trinidad and Tobago had players such as the Gomes brothers (Sheldon & Larry), Bernard Julien, Rangy Nanan, Bryan Davis, Phil Simmons, Gus Logie, Ian Bishop, Deryck Murray and Anthony Gray.

[Gray and Clarke were as good as any of the well-established fast bowlers in the Caribbean but chances of making the team consistently was near on impossible. They both had stellar careers in English county cricket.]

  • In 1980, the Jamaican regional team included  Michael Holding, Jeffrey Dujon, Everton Mattis, Herbert Chang, Basil Williams, Richard Austin, and Lawrence “Yagga” Rowe. The last 4 mentioned came from 1 local club, Kensington. [Back then for years, in a country of 14 parishes, Jamaica’s first-class cricket was played by teams exclusively based in Kingston/St Andrew with 1 other team coming from St Catherine.]
  • The Barbadian team that played Jamaica in 1980 included household names such as Desmond Haynes, Malcolm Marshall, Collis King, Sylvester Clarke, David Murray, Joel Garner and Wayne Daniel. They could also have called on the services Gordon Greenidge, Franklyn Stephenson and regional runs machine, Carlisle Best.
  • The Combined or Windward/Leeward islands had the likes of Andy Roberts, Viv Richards, Richie Richardson, Winston Davis, Norbert Phillip, Eldine Baptitse, Winston and Kenny Benjamin, Ralston Otto and later on Curtly Ambrose.

With such quality then why should the Caribbean have settled on just one international team instead of 5 or 6? A golden opportunity was missed when cricket in the West Indies was king.

West Indian Identity

The concept of West Indies cricket stems from the British colonial age that lingers on in subtle guises.

Luminaries such as the writer C.L.R. James felt that the notion of Team West Indies cricket was the perfect model of the kind of integration that should be mirrored across other aspects of Caribbean society. James was passionate about a federation of Caribbean islands.

The Caribbean can look to rugby union and the example of UK international teams of Ireland, Wales, Scotland and England who each play independently; but every 4 years the top players from these 4 nations form the British Lions team and tour overseas to play either South African, Australia or New Zealand in 3 test matches.

International cricket on a whole suffers from having too fewer top nations and the addition of 5/6 new teams from the Caribbean could bring renewed interest from local fans and investment to help take this great sport forward in the region and wider cricketing public.

Today, the likes of Barbados, Guyana and Trinidad & Tobago have solid domestic cricket programmes and infrastructure to make a viable case for international status. The Windward and Leeward Islands have made some of the biggest strides in cricket development especially in terms of modern cricketing grounds and facilities.

Jamaica is not far behind but has continued to produce players of international level. These Caribbean teams can also tap local talent from the diaspora in the UK and elsewhere including the USA.

The 5/6 national teams in the Caribbean have the coaches, the former players (mentors) and fan base both at home and in the diaspora to support such an initiative towards independent cricket.

Caribbean Bloc – Politics & Sport Mixture

The working relationship between West Indies cricket teams and their board of directors has rarely ever been harmonious. Forever fractious and at times the tension revolves around national lines. The West Indian boardroom members are still at loggerheads today. Shame.

If the West Indies (when they were number 1 & box office) was carved up into test playing nations and acted as a bloc they could have had a greater influence in the boardroom of the International Cricket Council (ICC). As a bloc of 5-6 votes the West Indian suits could have greater leverage to acquire more revenue and games for themselves.

In international football, the UK has 4 national team(s) & administrations (England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland). In the boardrooms of FIFA and UEFA these 4 UK nations have long stuck together as a bloc of 4 to influence football policy to their way of thinking, much to the annoyance of some other members.

The traditional purists will think this suggested breaking of the West Indies cricket is a pointless and expensive exercise. But West Indies cricket officials need to finally look at the bigger picture of international cricket.

Why have they held back their respective nations from playing global cricket whilst other less traditional nations (e.g. Ireland) have caught up with them in the various rankings?

The fact that the likes of Afghanistan, Ireland, Scotland, Namibia, UAE, The Netherlands, Kenya and indeed Bangladesh have made great strides to be in top the 20 rankings of international cricket. Such meteoric strides just shows up how the Caribbean has sat on their complacent laurels a missed having greater influence on pitch and in the corridors of power.

Following West Indies’ victory over Bangladesh in the first test, Jofra Archer (England/Barbados) tweeted “Barbados has so much talent it’s unbelievable”.

Damn right.

Barbados team late 1970s incl. Trotman, Garner, Skeete, Haynes, Farmer, Murray, Padmore, Holder, Holford, Greenidge, King



About africanherbsman1967

Ideas Man
This entry was posted in Caribbean, cricket and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Time for West Indies Cricket to Break Up?

  1. Thomas says:

    I would love to see a WI team that was right up there making even the very best nervous. My opinions are perhaps coloured by the fact that when I first got into following cricket WI were the benchmark of excellence, with Greenidge, Haynes, Richards, Dujon and any number of top quality fast bowlers combining to make most opponents look feeble. I actually think that now after 20+ years of being in the wilderness there is once again a depth of talent available for WI to become once more a true cricketing powerhouse.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s